Precious Water

Precious Water
Water, essence of life

Wednesday 9 May 2012

Three stories, same tale

Recently, I watched Iron Lady and this brought me back to 1979, the year I graduated. After going through multiple loops of IQ tests, interviews I was offered a job with ICL (Intl Computers Ltd), UK. My thoughts back then was to work in London for a few years. I remembered the offer came by telegram. I was all excited, shipped my things to London and was ready to head home for a break before returning to work. Within 2 weeks of my offer, ICL withdrew, thanks to Margaret Thatcher. I must add ICL was gracious to compensate me 1 month salary. Welcome to citizens first!

Margaret Thatcher came into power at about the most turbulent time post WWII, having to fight militant unions, unemployment and the IRA. As a student, I remembered bizarre strikes such as bakery, rail, postmen, policemen, firemen, buses, coal miners. She fought tooth and nail in many quarters and subsequently brought on a much stronger UK. During her watch, she was almost killed by a bomb plot on the last night at the Conservative Party conference in Brighton. She fought a principled, but expensive, war with the Argentineans over Falkland, thousands of miles away from home.

At home in late Apr12, a well respected don, Dr Tan Khee Giap suggested giving Singaporeans "first bite of the cherry" in jobs. The resounding message from the Government right now is Singaporeans come first.

Let me relate 3 stories I heard in the past 16 months. Story 1 was related to me by an ICT Singaporean honcho early last year. This person lamented that for a huge ICT project in SG, the person taking notes (minutes of meetings) is a foreigner. So I asked, "don't you have a say?" Unfortunately not, my HQ is in the West. I subsequently gathered their project director went through several iterations of Westerner, ABC, then Westerner and last I heard a local. I am not sure if the foreign scriber is still there.

Story 2 smacks colonialism. This person I chatted with worked for a smallish European company specialising in ERP domain. He is the only Singaporean director amongst a dozen European directors. He is the company's "poster boy", propped upwards whenever there is a large Government project.
According to him, his fellow European directors simply do not have a clue on how business is conducted here; have no local network or ground information. Furthermore, all were on expat terms. How they continue to remain business viable is questionable. His own boss apparently instructed not to be "disturbed" whenever he goes on leave. On the other hand, this local chap is required to be "voice contactable" on his vacation days. Last I heard, he held his own, moved on to a more level playing field; good for him.
Story 3 involves a large French company. Within weeks of hiring this local person at management level, his foreign boss forwarded some CVs of fresh graduates from France with a "highly recommended" rating. So what would you do if you were in his shoes? To keep his job, he had no choice but to do the “politically right thing”, hire a few foreign talents.

A recent story is one of a German ICT management staff, seconded to Singapore, trying to help bring across a secretary support person. I don’t know if his barber is coming too!

Based on these anecdotal cases, I am not entirely surprise such practice takes place in the ICT segment. Unlike professionals such as doctors, lawyers or finance with unique skills, ICT has hardly any entry barrier. Anyone with some resemblance of ICT related training can land on our shores, stay to work, subject to basic scrutiny.


Fast forward 33 years and history repeats itself in the UK. It is in technical recession, exchange rate at the lowest for decades and Europe is groping in the dark, reluctant to take the austerity route. Meanwhile, my kid, followed my footsteps, is bent on seeking for a job in London upon graduation this year. It's humbling when you send out hundreds of emails and a handful replied. However, the rigour of going through tests, case studies, interviews is still invaluable.

I continue to cheer her on knowing "what don't kill you makes for a better man, woman included". Presently, it may be easier to strike lottery than landing a job in the UK. Understandably, locals come first again!

We are a migrant society, highly tolerant and conditioned to accept and embrace change. All things equal, we need to take care and grow our own timber as well. We owe no apologies.

FTR: I am "colour agnostic", having 8 nationalities in my work team, including Singaporeans.